Architecture Thesis Project, 2023

The Value of Decay: Accessing the ruins of Lumsdale

This project explores how decay can be maintained and embraced by integrating new additions that rest, float and wrap around the existing ruins of Lumsdale, Matlock.

Painted study of the proposed visitors courtyard — sage-green roofs on the retained barn walls, gardens in the foreground.

Problem

The enriching history of Lumsdale’s ruins cannot be experienced as they are shut off from the public for safety concerns.

Conventional heritage methods that control decay would strip away their rich identity and history.

“By accepting ongoing processes (of ruination) we may in fact be opening ourselves up to a more meaningful and reciprocal relationship with the material past.”

DeSilvey, 2017
Danger, unsafe building, keep out — warning signs wired to the fence that seals the ruins off.
Restricted access to existing ruins
The ruined smithy at Lumsdale — an ivy-covered chimney beside a circular stone trough and timber fence.
Existing Ruin

Initial Concept

Exploring how the existing can be minimally disrupted when combined with the new. The exploration below felt too overpowering over the existing

Cardboard study model — a solid new volume seated on the ruin wall.
Cardboard study model — the volume raised clear on the wall head.
Cardboard study model — a leaning roof plane sheltering the fragments.

Developed Concept

Analysing precedents to develop a much lighter interaction with minimal disruption to the existing condition

Fragment model studying the Hedmark Museum — a timber frame floating above a white plaster ruin wall.
Case study - Hedmark Museum, Floating Columns
Fragment model of a proposed support — a sage timber canopy resting gently against a modelled stone ruin.
Support exploration - a gentle addition

Solution

Curate and maintain decay through a series of light interventions and pathways that connect the ruins whilst keeping visitors safe.

Proposed axonometric of Lumsdale Valley — sage-roofed interventions, walled gardens and a raised pathway threaded between the ruins, down to the lake.
Proposed Axonometric